• Gabbai

Chukat – A Major League Minor Matter


Image

Twice the nation of Israel attempted to cross into the promised land. At first they Approached Edom. Moses sent messengers to the king of Edom asking for passage through their land. Their request was declined and when Moses reiterated the request they responded with aggression. Edom being the land of Esau’s descendants, Israel did not wish to provoke a battle and they turned away. Some time later Israel sent messengers to Sichon, King of the Amorites, asking for passage through their land. Sichon immediately mobilized his armies and advanced upon Israel. They were soundly defeated and Israel acquired their lands.

The request for passage deserves our attention, as numerous discussions are sparked from these verses. The request, both to the Edomites and later to the Amorites, stipulated that they would pass in the manner most convenient to the inhabitants of the land. (Numbers 20:14-21, 21:21-22) They would not pass through fields and orchards, as this would alarm the farmers, who feared raids of their produce. They would also not drink water from the wells.

In Deuteronomy, when Moses recalls this event, he records the message as follows: “Sell me food for money that I will eat, and water for money you will give me and I’ll drink, only let me pass with my feet.” (Deuteronomy 2:28) Rash”i states that the intent was that they would not drink water from their own well of Miriam, which traveled with them. Instead, they would purchase water and provisions from the local inhabitants, supporting the economy and bringing tourist dollars into the country. From here, states Rashi, we learn the importance of showing gratitude to our hosts. When visiting another location one should purchase food from the locals even if one has provisions.

The Talmud (Avoda Zara 37b) quotes this verse in the context of something very different. The Talmud discusses those foods which had been prohibited by the sages from eating. Aside from foods which are inherently non